"I Can’t Get No Respect!"
(Showing Respect)

PURPOSE: By the end of this session, I want my students to see the importance of respecting themselves and others and have some practical ways to put these attitudes into action.

Introduction

OPENING DISCUSSION: Have any of you seen comedian Rodney Dangerfield in any movies? What line is he famous for? Often in his comedy routines you’ll hear him say, "I can’t get no respect." What do you think he means? 

One dictionary defines respect this way, "to have regard for or appreciation of a person’s worth; to honor, to esteem, to be courteous and considerate to."

WHY IS RESPECT IMPORTANT?  

In order to see the importance of showing respect, let's try to relive the feelings that come with being disrespected.  

MOVIE CLIP: (Either use the clip or remind them of this section of the movie.) In the hit movie, Back to the Future, Michael J. Fox plays Marty McFly, a student whose father was treated without respect all his life. Marty goes back in time and sees the abuse that his father endured in school. I want to show you a clip so that you can feel the humiliation along with him.

(Show a clip where Biff, the bully, cuts down Marty’s father as he pressures him to get his homework done. Then, run the movie back toward the beginning of the movie where we see Marty’s dad being his nerdy self in his home.  If you can't use the clip, verbally describe the scene: Marty’s father, now seen as a teenager in the past, was eating in the lunchroom when Biff and his henchmen approach him and ask how he's coming along with Biff’s homework. Biff ends up telling Marty’s father how gullible he is. At the first of the movie we find Marty's father as a grown-up, still doing Biff's work for him and being disrespected.)

Hint: The purpose of showing or describing a familiar movie clip is to move students past merely defining respect to feeling what it’s like to receive disrespect. It’s critical to tap into their strong feelings here if we want to see true life change. Plenty of more current movies, such as "Spiderman" show youth being shown disrespect by other students.

DISCUSSION BASED ON CLIP: Because of being treated like a loser in high school, Marty’s father lost his self-respect and ended up being a loser as an adult. When people treat others as losers, when they put others down instead of respecting them, it affects people profoundly. Some lose their confidence and are never able to take risks in life.

BRAINSTORM CHALLENGE!  

Divide the class into two teams, right down the middle of the class. Each team chooses a fast writer for the blackboard. Each team is to come up with as many examples of how people show disrespect as they can. They can use examples from school, home or community. After three minutes, ask them to come up with examples of how to show respect. After three minutes, count up the legitimate items on each side. Losers serve donuts to the winners, then themselves.

Debriefing: Which items that were listed bother you the most? Why? How do you think we can begin showing more respect to people? 

Disrespect hurts. Some never get over the hurt. You know how it feels. Let's move from understanding the problem to becoming part of the solution. Here are some steps for treating others with respect.

STEP 1: See People for their Future Potential, Not Their Present Limitations

Hint: Students usually assume that people will be as they are now forever. But think through those who graduated with you. Some of the "nerds" are probably movers and shakers in today’s world. Some of the former "cool crowd" are probably now considered losers. Perhaps by giving some examples of these from your own experience, you could help students see that after high school, a "Great Reverse" often occurs. We have no idea what others will become. Realizing this can help them have more respect for everyone, regardless of their present status.

DISCUSSION: Does everyone deserve at least some respect? Why or why not? (Allow them to beat this around a bit.) I’d argue that although some people have earned our respect and thus deserve a higher degree of respect than others, all people deserve at least our courtesy. Why? Because all people have the potential to be something great. No matter how worthless a person may seem now, if someone were to only look beneath the surface and treat that person with some dignity, that person may very well become a totally different person.

ILLUSTRATION #1: Do you remember the part in the movie "Aladdin" when Jafar first approached the entrance to the vast cave of treasures? A voice boomed out that only one person would be allowed to enter. The voice said, "Bring me the…" What was he called? ("The diamond in the rough.") What do you think was meant by that phrase? (A diamond in the rough doesn’t look very beautiful. This is the way Aladdin appeared. He was born poor and had become a thief. But he aspired to be more. He didn’t look good on the outside, but he had the potential to be great.)

So, let’s treat people like they may be great one day, rather than as we see them today.

ILLUSTRATION #2: A young teenager named Steven didn't fit in at Middle School. All the other students thought that to be important you had to be good at sports like baseball. But Steven was a terrible player. And to make matters worse, he looked funny. Schoolmates would call him names. But Steven took an interest in photography and movies and found other people in his neighborhood who shared his interests. He wasn’t accepted any better in high school, where he called the artsy crowd his "Leper colony". But even in school plays he couldn’t get parts because he couldn’t remember the lines. So he just worked on the sets. But he continued to develop his interests in film and became famous as one of the greatest producers in the history of film. Anyone want to guess his name? Steven Spielberg. (Ask youth to name as many movies produced by Spielberg that they can remember.) The same people who laughed at him in school and called him "Spielbug" would probably love to have his autograph now. Or at least a week's salary!

So what can we learn from this illustration? (No matter how much of a loser someone seems like today, we can't see his or her future. It would have been easy to put down guys like Albert Einstein, Tom Cruise, and Steven Spielberg when they were teens. Let's see fellow students as diamonds in the rough. 

STEP 2: Realize the Incredible Power of Encouragement.

Solomon, a king who was known for his great wisdom, once said, "Death and life are in the power of the tongue." What do you think he meant by that? (Get some discussion.)

Say the wrong thing to the wrong person at the wrong time and that person may commit suicide. Others may be harmed for life.

What do you think of the little saying, "Sticks and stones may break my bones but words can never harm me."? I wish it were true. But it’s not. Words can dramatically change people’s lives.

But the tongue can also be powerful for good. Most of us haven’t grasped its power. Say the right thing to the right person at the right time and you may very well save a person’s life.

STEP 3: Become a Diamond Cutter

I often hear musicians say that when they get a letter from a fan that says they were positively impacted by one of their songs, it makes all their effort worth the while. But we don’t have to be popular musicians to share that same great feeling of having impacted someone’s life. Each of us can turn "diamonds in the rough" into incredible diamonds. For many students, parents and teachers, it just takes a little respect and encouragement from a student who cares. Why become a "diamond cutter?"

1. It will help you in your vocation.

How do you think that respecting others and encouraging them will help you succeed in your vocation? (Get some response. This should be more conversational than lecture.)

ILLUSTRATION: Charles Schwab was so highly valued by his employer that he was paid one million dollars per year. Not a bad salary. Why was he deemed so valuable to the company? In Schwab's own words,

"I consider my ability to arouse enthusiasm among my people the greatest asset I possess; and the way to develop the best that is in a person is by appreciation and encouragement. I believe in giving a person incentive to work. So I am anxious to praise but loath to find fault. If I like anything, I am hearty in my approbation and lavish in my praise."

Employers want employees who know how to bring the best out of others. Showing respect and encouragement is one of the best ways.

2. It meets people’s deepest needs.

Educator John Dewey once stated that the deepest urge in human nature is "the desire to be important."

Psychologist William James said, "The deepest principle in human nature is the craving to be appreciated."

If Dewey and James are on target, then the person who can meet this need has great power to influence others. Let me tell you about a study of some youth that put this to the test. Tell me what you think the result was.

ILLUSTRATION: A study was conducted of 12 to 14 year olds. One group of children were told to run around a track and that they would be timed. No matter how well they did, the instructor told them, "I don't know what the problem is, but you are not as fast as the other groups. Let's try again."

A second group also ran the track. But this group was encouraged about their performance. They told them that they were very fast.

Which group do you think began to run faster and faster? (Let them respond.) The first group (that received the discouraging report) ran slower and slower with each succeeding run. Yet the second group ran faster with each run. The words of encouragement powerfully motivated them to perform better.

ILLUSTRATION: I heard a story of an unruly boy who was sent to the principal's office for his bad behavior in school. Apparently this was not the first time, and the principal looked at the boy, pondering what to do. This time, instead of scolding him, he looked down at the boy's hands. He told the boy, "Look at your hands. Thin fingers. Those are surgeon's hands. Go, fulfill your potential." All the boy could do that day was to look at his hands. Years later the principal heard from the boy, who had now completed medical school to be a surgeon. The turning point in the boy's life? The day he was encouraged by the principal.

One of the greatest feelings in the world is that you have positively impacted someone else’s life. One day I hope you can say,

I don’t think there’s any greater feeling than knowing that I’ve had a part in making a diamond in the rough into a beautiful stone. Start respecting and encouraging others and you will watch people blossom before your eyes.

STEP 3: Know How to Respect and Encourage Others

ACTIVITY: Let’s divide into groups of 4 or 5. Often it is cool to be critical, uncool to be positive. How can we overcome the momentum and become an encourager? Appoint a secretary to write down your ideas and appoint someone else to share these with the large group when we finish. Here are two things to write down:

(As they share their ideas, you may want to use the following points and activities to either add to or reinforce what they share. Don't lecture! Let them share!)

1. Say encouraging and respectful words!

ILLUSTRATION: A book called The One Minute Manager has been very popular in America. In the book, a successful manager tells an inquirer about his secrets of management. Here’s one of his secrets: when a person begins a new job in his company, he watches him closely for a period of time. Why? "To catch him doing something wrong" we assume. No. This manager watches closely to catch him doing something right, so that he has the opportunity to praise him. He found that reinforcing good behavior and skills with praise was one of the most powerful ways to bring out the best in his workers.

Don't flatter. What do you think is the difference between flattery and respect? (Let students respond) (Flattery tells lies to people in order to get them to like you.) Instead, look for opportunities to give people honest and sincere praise.

Do you work at a job where you could try this with new workers? What about with a little brother or sister when they learn a new skill? Try applying it with schoolmates. Have your radar on constantly, trying to catch people doing something right, so that you can say a word of praise. You may never know how those words impact their lives.

ILLUSTRATION: A forty year old man still vividly remembers a remark from over 25 years ago when his older brother commented, "When you wash the motorcycle, I don’t see how you get it looking so good. I can’t seem to do it that well." Maybe he said it in hopes that his brother would clean the cycle every week! Whatever his motivation, something as simple as that left a big impression. Do you have a younger brother or sister? You may have no idea how you can mold their lives by simple compliments like these.

ACTIVITY: Put your chairs in a circle, with one chair in the middle. The middle chair is "The Chair of Encouragement." I’d like for Natalie (choose someone that people know well, so that students will have something good to say) to start us off. Come on, have a seat! None of us know what kind of week Natalie may have had. She might be on the brink of a nervous breakdown as far as we know. What are some things you could say about Natalie that would remind her of why she is special? Or perhaps there is something Natalie said or did for you that meant a lot, and you’d like to complement her for it. (Give several people time to share. This is not a time to be goofy, but to give honest and sincere praise. It can be a very meaningful experience. If you have time, ask a few others to come to the chair. CAUTION: Don’t put someone in the chair that no one knows, or that everyone hates!)

2. Write a Note!

ILLUSTRATION: Notes can be powerful. At a youth retreat, one of the girls got sick. The youth minister and a few youth wrote her a note to encourage her. The writers probably soon forgot all about the note, but years later she showed the youth minister a note that she still kept in her pocketbook. It was the same note!

3. Remember people's interests, names, and important events.

If a fellow student, teacher or family member shares a special concern with you, make sure to ask them about how it is going at a later time. Remembering people's interests and concerns is a way of telling them that their interests are important and they matter.

CONCLUSION

We began with a clip from the movie Back to the Future where we found Marty’s dad living as an adult nerd. But when Marty spent time with his high school dad, Marty treated him with respect, encouraged him to respect himself and told him that he should consider publishing the science fiction he had been writing privately. The end of the story? Did any of you see the movie? When Marty went back to the future, what was his dad like? His dad was no longer a "diamond in the rough." He was a successful writer who was no longer a nerd. (You may want to show the clip toward the end of the film.) By encouraging this student in high school, Marty changed his entire future. Do you realize the impact of this? Do you think that by simply bringing out the best in someone else you could change their entire future?

Action Points

Write down a few names of people that you need to encourage about something, people you've caught doing something right. They could be parents, brothers or sisters, teachers, administrators or schoolmates. If they are in this room, don't let them leave without saying something encouraging to them. If they're not in this room, consider writing them a note. Who knows? Something you say or write today could change a person’s entire future. I hope many of us will find the incredible joy of becoming diamond cutters.

Recommended Reading: Bringing Out the Best in People, Alan Loy McGinnis, (Augsburg, 1985).

Further Ideas

Don't think your class will go for some of my ideas? Substitute games, activities, and stories from our large collection on the page  "Respect for Others."  

Copyright August 24, 2000 by Legacy Educational Resources. All rights reserved. 

Student Handout and/or Overhead

"I Can’t Get No Respect!"
(Respecting Our Selves and Others)

Discussion based on "Back to the Future:"

How do you see people showing disrespect to others? How do they show disrespect to you?

STEPS TO SHOWING RESPECT:

STEP 1: See People for their Future __________, Not Their Present ____________.

Does everyone deserve at least some respect? Why or why not?

STEP 2: Realize the Incredible Power of _______________.

The following statement was made over 2000 years ago: "Death and life are in the power of the tongue." What does that mean to you?

STEP 3: Become a _____________ Cutter

A. Why Encourage and Respect Others?

1. It will help you in your ___________.

Why was Charles Schwab paid $1,000,000 per year?

2. It meets people’s deepest __________.

"Those are Surgeon’s Hands."

B. How to Respect and Encourage _____________